May 9, 2008
Did a book traumatize you, once upon a time?
Posted by the Monkey under Libraries and children, booksHere’s an interesting piece from the SFGate.com site - “Books that traumatized you as a child,” by Peter Hartlaub, who also wrote about movies that traumatized kids. Hartlaub doesn’t seem to have actually been traumatized by a book (in my experience, books don’t send most kids into terror and anxiety the way that visual and sound media - namely movies and TV shows - do).
But he does write that he doesn’t understand the appeal of Maurice Sendak’s Where the Wild Things Are.
I think part of the problem was it was introduced to me when I was really young, and had never seen anything more challenging in content than a Richard Scarry book. While I completely respect the artwork and Maurice Sendak’s story, the image of a little boy in his pajama-looking wolf suit wandering around without dinner in a spooky monster-filled woods was too depressing for me to enjoy.
It’s interesting, though, to see the books listed in the comments. Those who wrote in hated, or were frightened by, Bread and Jam for Frances, The Red Pony, and Where the Red Fern Grows. The last one, at least, is completely understandable, but I think that the books (and media) that bother or scare us as kids are often completely peculiar to our own experiences. Once, in a library where I worked years ago, there was a child who attended storytime weekly who was not only scared of insects of any kind, but he couldn’t bear to hear any story or song with bugs in it. If he heard “There was an old lady who swallowed a fly,” for example, his eyes grew wide, he’d start whimpering, and his mom had to scoop him up and take him out.
I hope he grew out of it.
Did I book ever traumatize me? I can’t really remember. I thought Where the Wild Things Are was an extremely cool story, myself. For me, it was scary TV shows. There are still a few episodes of Twilight Zone that I remember scared the bejezus out of me when I was eight or nine…

May 9, 2008 at 4:39 pm
My husband is still traumatized by The Velveteen Rabbit…
May 9, 2008 at 4:39 pm
Gimme a break. The only one I can think of is a book on the holocaust that I came across in 5th grade. It freaked me out (and fascinated me) mostly because I’d never really been exposed to the whole idea before that. Same thing in high school when I read a book on the 1918 flu epidemic. “Why aren’t we studying THIS in history?” I wondered…
May 9, 2008 at 5:10 pm
Teacherninja– I spent much of high school reading history books because I kept asking that same question - “Why aren’t we studying THIS [the good, interesting stuff] in history?” –W
May 9, 2008 at 5:23 pm
The only books in my childhood that may have traumatized me were The Giving Tree and A Prayer for a Child. The former: as Erasure sings, “Who Needs Love Like That?” The latter: Fuse #8 points out that this book may have inspired all of the “Precious Moments” statues. Aaaaaaaaah! [Hides under the bed.]
May 10, 2008 at 2:25 am
I was totally terrified of “Bartholomew and the Oobleck” by Dr. Seuss. C’mon. The thought of it STILL freaks me out a little bit. WHAT IF OOBLECK STARTED FALLING FROM THE SKY?! Do you honestly think our country would be prepared for a disaster like that!?
May 12, 2008 at 6:28 pm
There’s an interesting interview where Sendak talks about how he views writing and illustrating for children here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mZTQib7G2Hs
It’s part of “There’s a Mystery There: Sendak on Sendak” at the Rosenbach Museum in Philadelphia. http://www.rosenbach.org.